Title: Caraval (Caraval #1)
Author: Stephanie Garber
Target audience: Young adult
Date Read: 17/09/18 – 21/09/18
I decided to pick up this book because I was in a circus mood for quite a while and this seemed an obvious choice. It wasn’t terrible, and I liked a lot of the ideas, but I ultimately felt everything was just a bit underdeveloped.
I’m going to start with the romance because that was probably the thing that stood out the most to me and not in a great way. Mostly because it only took place over five days, and I’m sorry, it’s not true love after a week. I’m not saying you can’t be attracted to someone in that time, but from Julien’s perspective, particularly, it wasn’t enugh time for such strong feelings to develop. And from Scarlett’s perspective, I didn’t buy that he was as important to her as her beloved sister after only a few nights.
Speaking of the characters in more general terms, I didn’t feel like they had a whole lot of personality. I will say I did like Scarlett’s development from doormat to… well, I won’t say she became badass, but she definitely became less doormat-y and grew into her own.
The plot and world-building had similar issues. I just wished everything was a bit… more. A bit more magic, a bit more exploration of the island, a bit more explanation of who Legend was and how and why Caraval was the way it was… There was a line in the last third that said something along the lines of “Scarlett had been collecting buttons since she’d been here” and my first response was “… had she?” Because nothing was memorable.
I also had some issues with the reveals in the final chapter. I know we were supposed to think the character orchestrating everything was terribly clever, but… it seemed far-fetched, and honestly made this character seem like a bit of a psycopath to put Scarlett through it all?
Having said all of that! I actually am still intrigued enough by this world that I am interested in reading the sequel. So make of that what you will.
4 thoughts on ““I love you, Tella.” “I know. I wouldn’t be here if you didn’t.” // Review of “Caraval” by Stephanie Garber”
I’m so happy to read this review because people just seem to LOVE this book and I…..didn’t. I think your points are very valid and I agree with them all. Can I add how much I hated her sister? Loved this review.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, Tella was kind of awful! She really didn’t seem to grasp at all how her plan and actions affected Scarlett and how she’s probably messed Scarlett up for the rest of her life!
LikeLiked by 1 person